Alleges Violation of the Commerce Clause by Limiting Sale of SRECs to Solar Facilities Connected to the Distribution Grid of The State of New Jersey
New Jersey's electricity suppliers and utilities satisfy the State of New Jersey Renewable Portfolio Standards by purchasing SRECs from solar facilities connected to the distribution system of New Jersey. Solar facilities in PJM not sited in New Jersey cannot qualify. The Attorney General of West Virginia has brought suit against the New Jersey BPU arguing that this exclusion of out-of-state SRECs harms the citizens of West Virginia and New Jersey as well as solar owners in West Virginia.
| Vintage | Nov 19, 2026 | Nov 12, 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2027 NJ SREC | $175 | $175 | $0 |
| 2028 NJ SREC | $145 | $160 | −$15 |
| 2029 NJ SREC | $125 | $150 | −$25 |
| 2030 NJ SREC | $115 | $140 | −$25 |
| 2031 NJ SREC | $100 | $125 | −$25 |
| 2032 NJ SREC | $90 | $100 | −$10 |
The suit targets all three New Jersey solar incentives, arguing that Legacy SRECs, TRECs and SuSi SREC IIs (successor SRECs) violate the Commerce Clause.
The suit requests judgment and relief for the following:
The solar incentives in New Jersey were designed to spur investment in solar within the State of New Jersey to benefit New Jersey homeowners, businesses, schools, New Jersey labor and solar businesses. Lobbying was done by NJ labor unions and NJ-based solar installers in the creation of the New Jersey solar laws. Limiting SREC payments to solar facilities located on the distribution system of New Jersey accomplished those goals.
$21 billion was invested to install 6 GW of solar, supplying 9.5% of the electricity in New Jersey. West Virginia did not provide incentives like New Jersey. It has only 4% of the solar that New Jersey has and generates only half of one percent of its power needs from solar. NJ SREC payments provided the incentives for solar investment in New Jersey. Opening the SREC market to out-of-state SRECs, as demanded by the suit, would collapse the price of the SREC market, harming most of the solar investors in New Jersey.
The high cost of electricity is a top political issue in New Jersey. High and increasing renewable mandates are a large portion of the cost and one of the only factors that can be controlled politically in the short term. The total cost of New Jersey environmental RPS compliance was approximately $1.4 billion in 2025. The 2025 in-state carve-out costs pinpointed in this suit are SRECs at $631 million, TRECs at $141 million and SuSi at $63 million.
New Jersey politicians attempted to eliminate the SREC costs in the spring of 2025 by introducing bills into the NJ Legislature. The bills were not pursued because it was an election year and legislators did not want to lose votes by cutting payments to solar investors in New Jersey. Conveniently, the blame can now be directed to the Attorney General of West Virginia.
If out-of-state SRECs are allowed to be used by electricity suppliers in New Jersey for their RPS compliance, the SREC segment of the market will become oversupplied. NJ SREC prices will most likely move down to a slight premium to Class I RECs, which are currently trading at $27 in the wholesale market for 2027 compliance. This would hypothetically represent an 80% reduction in cost.
In reality, however, ratepayers would not see that cost reduction. Most electricity in New Jersey is contracted three years in advance through BPU-sanctioned auctions, so true ratepayer savings would not materialize. Instead, electricity suppliers in New Jersey would reap a short-term windfall if out-of-state SRECs were allowed for New Jersey compliance.
NJ SREC costs sunset in the next few years as solar investors are fully paid. They are replaced by a combination of new SuSi solar investments and increased RPS compliance for Class I RECs. Almost all of the money for New Jersey Class I RECs is paid to out-of-state renewable energy facilities, primarily wind. $600 million was paid by New Jersey ratepayers to other states in 2025, and that will increase to $1 to $1.5 billion a year by 2030.
West Virginia is suing the New Jersey BPU, but the BPU is simply following laws passed by the New Jersey Legislature that restrict RPS compliance to solar facilities connected to the New Jersey distribution system. The New Jersey Legislature is the entity that should be named in the suit; the BPU cannot change state law.
The Legislature could change the law to allow out-of-state solar. This would collapse the price of NJ SRECs and reduce costs to New Jersey ratepayers, while harming solar investors in New Jersey. The Legislature already floated a bill to do exactly this in the spring of 2025, and this suit could be used as cover to reduce political backlash. The suit does not even have to be pursued and decided for the New Jersey Legislature to take proactive action.
A link to the lawsuit can be found here.
Read the Attorney General’s statement here.